Apple sued by troll for packaging a headset with its phones

It’s official, the patent system is properly broken. As noted by GigaOM, the US Patent Office had released a statement saying there was nothing wrong with the system, telling the people who thought otherwise to “give it a rest”. As if we needed more evidence than the last couple of years worth of patent infringement suits, here’s a classic for you.

A shell firm in California has filed an infringement suit against Apple, asking for $3 million in damages because Apple packaged a headset with the iPhone. The patent is named “Wireless Mobile Phone Including a Headset” or US Patent 7,373,182. Incredibly general, and a fine example of a patent troll doing what it does best: trying to get money for coming up with an idea that is common sense. I mean, seriously, headsets are packaged with almost every single mobile phone out there. But, the troll, Intelligent Smart Phones Concepts LLC (which – by the way, doesn’t manufacture or produce anything at all) is singling out Apple.

GigaOM speculates that this company is one run by a large, and well know patent troll, Intellectual Ventures owned and run by a former Microsoft employee. Sadly, this company makes a living from suing everyone for everything and sometimes wins.

Now, how about a patent system reform?

Via: GigaOM

Tags: , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
austinm2425 6 pts

You say that this company is a troll. Okay... You would think "Slide to Unlock" would be "common sense" as well but no. Now that a company gives Apple what they have been giving everyone else you get butt hurt.

SkyPira 30 pts

So you guys finally admit the patent system is broken, once apples on the other side of the fence? Ooookay. Apple deserves this nonsensical lawsuit for suing someone else for something just as nonsensical.

One3OneKing 11 pts

So NOW the system is broken? Forget the number of senseless lawsuits Apple started up. Apple getting sued for something that is "common sense" sounds like you may be defending logic that Apple has already rejected. How many things have Apple sued for being common sense. Rectangles anyone?

Serves them right. Lay off suing Samsung, then maybe Apple can talk about unfairness.

 

KarimBhaidani 5 pts

LOL like samsungs not suing apple with shit broken 3g patents Go home android hypocrite

BillThomas 27 pts

 KarimBhaidani they are android fan bitches that cant think on there own and the sad thing is over half of them have never even used an iPhone or iPod!!!1

SkyPira 30 pts

@BillThomas thats not true. I like android, yet have both an iPhone AND an iPod. Its a pretty big assumption to make, that just because you've used an apple product that you HAVE to like it as well.

SkyPira 30 pts

@BillThomas thats not true. I like android, yet have both an iPhone AND an iPod. Its a pretty big assumption to make, that just because you've used an apple product that you HAVE to like it as well.

austinm2425 6 pts

 BillThomas  KarimBhaidani We can't think for ourselves? Tell that to my roms and themes.

roboguy12 31 pts

@BillThomas @KarimBhaidani I think we can all go ahead and assume this is sarcasm, right? Nobody actually intends to put 1 in place of ! anymore.

austinm2425 6 pts

 KarimBhaidani And who started it? Everything was fine until Apple sued Samsung. Oh, did you forget that part.

BillThomas 27 pts

 austinm2425  KarimBhaidani Apple tried to settle with samsung before they sued them..oh did u forget that part, and for the record i have had android phones and they was junk

roboguy12 31 pts

"Sadly, this company makes a living from suing everyone for everything..." wait, we're NOT talking about the company that tries to patent a black rectangle with a glass front, or that claims a tap is a zero-distance swipe?

ldominguez1986 10 pts

I love my Apple products but not the company I buy them from. If anyone is a troll it's Apple. Suing people who are doing better than them to knock them down a few pegs. That's sad. Let me feel bad for a multi billion dollar company

HansKwazneski 8 pts

Hahaha, serves Apple right! The more lawsuits against them the better. I love my Mac, but DAMN Apple has shit the bed since Jobs passed :(

I bet it'd be different if it was Apple suing Samsung over the packaging of the headphones...

TiP_Cam 64 pts moderator

I think what you're failing to see, is that if this lawsuit is successful, they can sue absolutely any company that happens to ship a headset with its phones. Just in case you weren't sure: that's pretty much every manufacturer, ever. 

ldominguez1986 10 pts

@TiP_Cam Just like Apple suing for people using squares, lock screen, etc... These are also widely used. Apple is patenting general shapes and that's not trolling? Come on

One3OneKing 11 pts

 TiP_Cam You're right and they chose to sue Apple. Perhaps this is just a consumer attempting to give apple a dose of their own medicine. I hope this person wins.

Chief738 5 pts

@TiP_Cam we can expect apple suing this company after for patent infringement of suing other companies

BillThomas 27 pts

 TiP_Cam I see what u are saying but all the android fan boys are to blind or stupid to see the point, all they see is the word Apple and the word lawsuit!!!!!

roboguy12 31 pts

 BillThomas  TiP_Cam First of all, liking Android doesn't automatically make one a "fanboy". Secondly, of course most people will recognize the irony/hypocrisy of a company, that for the better part of this past year has been patenting extremely broad and trivial aspects of a smartphone, to finally be sued on similar grounds. Granted, what this "troll" company is doing is wrong - suing Apple over a trivial and nonsensical patent - but what we "fanboys" are saying is that Apple has no right to complain, since that is exactly what they've been doing.

austinm2425 6 pts

 TiP_Cam However, they probably wouldn't. Why would they sue Apple first?