TiP off: The specs of Motorola Backflip vs. iPhone 3GS

Well, well, well — Android is finally hitting AT&T. While not formally announced at CES 2010, it was safe to assume then that the Motorola Backflip would be arriving at AT&T as its first Android smartphone. The Backflip certainly isn’t a top-of-the-line Nexus One or HTC Desire, but its presence on “Big Blue” won’t go unnoticed. With its quirky form factor and UI, will the Backflip pose a threat to the iPhone 3GS’s dominance on the carrier? Let’s take a quick look at the specs and see:

Processor. First off, let’s examine the processor. The iPhone 3GS currently clocks in at 600Mhz, while the Backflip comes slightly short at 528Mhz. That 72Mhz may not seem like an extravagant amount to you, but the Backflip’s UI, MotoBlur, certainly needs all the processing power it can get. In my opinion, MotoBlur slows down the phone too much, to the point where scrolling through your home screens becomes difficult.

Memory. The next item on our agenda is the RAM and ROM. RAM (random access memory) is the amount of memory the phone’s programs have to use. ROM (read-only memory) is the memory that stores the key programs of the device, like those that boot the device. When it comes to a device’s speed, processor and memory are key factors, and the Moto Backflip has 256 MB RAM and 512 MB ROM. While the Apple handset also has 256 MB RAM, its ROM is unknown. But 512 MB seems to be the industry standard, so its reasonable to assume the device is packing the same amount of memory, making the two handsets comparable.

Display. One thing we all crave is a nice, vibrant screen. Time and time again, the iPhone has proved itself to be the king of touchscreens. Specification-wise, it has a 3.5 inch size, 320 x 480 pixel resolution, capacitive multi touch, and an oleophobic coating (which helps prevent fingers from smudging the screen). The Backflip also has a capacitive display, but its a shrunken 3.1 inches. Like most Android devices, the Backflip also has no built-in multi touch. For iPhone users, this will be really noticeable — particularly in the web browser and photo gallery. In fact, this may be the deal breaker for many. As an iPod touch fanatic myself, I cannot begin to imagine a web-browsing experience without pinch-to-zoom and multi touch gestures.

Camera. The final comparison is that of the camera. The Backflip has a 5 MP autofocus camera, with an LED flash. The iPhone 3GS has a 3 MP autofocus camera, without any flash. But number of megapixels isn’t always the best way to judge a camera. In terms of photo quality, I’m sure there’ll be plenty of side-by-side images taken by both handsets once the Android phone debuts. One thing’s for sure though — a camera flash has been a much-desired feature on the iPhone for years, if only just to enable night-time picture-taking. Both the Backflip and the 3GS have photo-sharing capabilities.

Other specs. In terms of other specs, there are some similarities between the devices: They’re both 3G-enabled on AT&T’s network, and have an HTML web kit–based browser. (For the iPhone, that’s Safari.) Neither of the phones currently support Flash content, which means you can’t watch Hulu on either one. As for music, both devices have a multitude of audio formats, ranging anywhere from basic MP3 to ACC+. And they also have an e-compass and GPS. Both devices also have Wifi and Bluetooth, but the iPhone has the latest Bluetooth 2.1, while the Backflip has 2.0.   As for differences, what may be the biggest one is the keyboard: The Backflip has a physical full QWERTY keyboard that flips out from the back (hence the name), while the iPhone only has a virtual, on screen keyboard.

The Moto Backflip is certainly an entry-level handset to say the least. While it doesn’t directly compete with the iPhone 3GS, in my opinion, it certainly ushers in a new era of Android on AT&T. Only time will tell if it truly lives up to the hype of being the first Android device on “Big Blue.”

For reviews of the device, hit up our parent site PhoneDog.com. (We’re also working on getting the Backflip here in the house for a head-to-head comparison here at Today’s iPhone, so stay tuned.)

The Motorola Backflip is the first of several Android devices to debut on AT&T this year. It’s set to launch due March 7th.


Tags: , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Well, i have the backflip. And let me just tell you all i have had is trouble with this phone. First off all, the batery life sucks. A lot. Second, maybe i had a "lemon" of some sort, but i could not receive or send txt messages for the longest time, and i would get about 20 txts 2 days after the person actually sent them. I called the android customer service and i reset my phone. well it worked again for about a month, now when i call people, it sounds like im underwater and no, there is no water damage. So please, get the iphone.

sorry back flip but my iphone is the best I'm not trying to hat or nothing !!!! i was just saying!!!

Hey the backflip all day it has so many great apps and free apps more than iphone and I phone lags more 3g then backflip and now the backflip will be getting an android update from 1.5 to 2.1 and will get the flash player and be way faster.

fuck backflip they lose calls u need a iphone On the real !!!

i am getting a new phone tuesday or wensday and idk if i should get the backflip or the iphone 4... and i am a BIG TEXTER... which 1 is better for texting do u guys think??? HELP ME DECIDE PLZ..

omg!!!!/... i still dont know what to get... but for sure iphones camera really sucks... not like backflip,,,, oh my,,,, after reading all ur comments i think its down to backflip.. !!!

Well i have the backflip and im really loving it and hey it does just as well as the iphoine if not better.Another thing isu can go to att and get INSURANCE, if somthing happens to it lol........ and again i luv it.

i already have an ipod touch so ill proberly get the backflip

Im really confused aswell on weather to get the iphone or backflip maybe backflip

What are you looking for in a phone? Texting? gaming? Open Source-ness?

iPhone 4. There is no better phone on AT&T at this point.

well, the Samsung Captivate was announced for AT&T, so you can wait for this beast, or go for the iPhone 4. Either way, it'll be amazing check out Engadget for more info!

omg...seriously...i cant decide whether im gonna get the iphone or the backlfip...i have read comment about backflip that it has a poor battery life and freezes...but then overall its a great phone...

My next upgrade is next april my granpa said he would give his upgrade to me so I'm thinking about getting the backflip. Should I

wow!im due for an upgrade in a month..and i was lookin at phones...ive wanted the backflip since i saw it...(at first i thought it was stupid)but then i actually looked at it and its awesome!!i was at the store yesterday and one of the workers came up to me and was like"u could get the blackflip but ud have to pay an extra $30 every month for data..but my mom told him we have internet nd stuff already on it.and guess what!$30 extra every month went BYE-BYE :D but heres the thing..ive also wanted the iphone...UH-OH.he told me i could get it for justa few bucks more~yeah right!~(the baclflip is now $80) great! he made my life that more difficult! so i asked my friends.Some said Idk some said backflip.Some said iphone.Great help they are! i asked the ppl who had iphones at my school(2 gils) both said they hated it...and NO ONE had the backflip...it costs less too.and these comments helped too..oh and another thing..i currently have the LG vu..its okay.i HATE the touchscreen option only...i want the option of both qwerty keyboard and virtual qwerty keyboard..SOOOO guess which phone wins!!! :]]]] peace (\/)

Anyone know when will the Backflip be released in Asia?

NO IDEA WAT TO GET!!!!!!!!I AM FIXIN TO BE ABLE TO UPGRADE AND I DONT NO WAT TO GET!!!!!!!!!i lov txting my friends and i love PLAYING GAMES!!!!!they all say get the iphone but my reshearch says the backflip is better>IM CONFUSED!!!!!!!!!!!!!PLS HELP!!!

This is a dilemma many teens and young adults face: getting a higher end, but cooler device with games and apps, or a social-centric device. Personally, I'd wait about a month or so. Rumors of new AT&T phones are flying left and right! If you NEEDED a new phone right know, I'd get an iPhone, and then jailbreak it for all your social networking needs.

PS If Your phone is freezing, find a version of 2.1 that isn't destroyed the RAM sucking AT&T apps. Try XTC Developers, or just google Android ROM Developers. Careful not to brick. Another easy way to do this is to buy from over seas where they do more pay per minute, because those are sold directly from the manufacturer, not letting AT&T destroy them with pay apps no one wants.

All of these phones can be hacked and altered to your specs if you know what your doing. They're little computers. I've always HTC and Windows Mobile for it's ease to do this, but google shares that open spirit. iPhone and everything else Apple does is my way or the highway, and Steve Jobs tries so hard make decisions on technology for you. For puurely end users taht's fine, but I want options, and that's why I'd choose the back flip over a few little finger gestures.

Well I have had my backflip for about two nd a half weeks. I came from the iPhone 3G nd my brother has an iPhone 3Gs. Honestly, I loved the iPhone, I even actually got used to the keyboard, kinda. I had it jailbroken with a lot of apps/games, but I'd hardly EVER play them. I waited, nd waited, nd waited, . . . Nd waited for flash but nothing. After the longest wait for mms finally got it, just to find out its not as good as many other mms phones. Idk if it was jus my phone bt sometimes the touch screen would become unresponsive, or the web browser would crash. The WORST thing was the camera, picture quality was the worse I've ever seen. After I had an available upgrade I had to make a decision, get the iphone 3gs or blackberry bold, seeing as how the iphone 3gs was ok but not much different than the 3G, I decided to get the bold. I liked it, bt I was just used to touchscreen, the apps pretty much sucked though. So my brother wanted it and he had an upgrade, we traded, nd I found out about the backflip, researched, and decided I want it, so I got it. I grown to love this phone, I'm using it right now to write this comment. Yeah at&t put many unused apps that I wish I could delete, and changed google search to yahoo, but I just removed that widget, widgets something the iphone was missing, and set my homepage on the browser to google. Multitasking, perfect mms, MotoBlur, and perfect customization. Trust me I don't miss my iphone at all. In Q3 of 2010, this year, we will have the 2.1 update which should make it even better. My conclusion, if you care more about games for your phone, get the iphone, if u care more about social networking (like myself), get the backflip.

I sold my iPhone 3gs and bought backflip couple of days ago. I am glad I did because backflip is superior with Android OS. And other important thing is Android OS 2.1 upgrade is coming soon for backflip. That way you can browse the web with flash player 10.1 which is that will NEVER happen for iPhone because they are retards... That's what I call real web browsing, not 2 finger multitouch if there is no content...

I have an iPhone 3G and I want to get a backflip because I'm tired of not having a keyboard and the iPhone 3G can't take videos, it has no flash, and its not that good of quality for pictures. I need help and I don't know what to do. My two year contract is up in November so there might be cooler phones then but for now, please help me decide. Thanks. :)

Personally, I'd wait for the new iPhone 4G. It looks 10x better than the previous generations, and the 4.0 OS seems to be amazing. If a physical keyboard is a necessity, then you may want to look into the Backflip or even a Samsung Impression. The Impression has one of the greatest QWERTY keyboards I've ever seen. The proprietary AT&T/Samsung OS however is another story.

honestly i find the impression keyboard i little too squishy

If you're an att customer, you only have to wait 18 months from when your contract begins to upgrade your phone, not the whole 2 yrs.

Personally, I think that the iPhone is the winner here. The screen is better, the OS is slightly less 'premature' than Android 1.5. The Web Browsing experience is amazing. I personally think that the iPhone is not a toy for gaming, so I think that the Android Market has more to offer (rich variety of customization options ALONG WITH many games). The one thing the BackFlip may have over the iPhone's hardware may be the keyboard, which is decent at least. It's up to you. Do you want a messaging-centric device, or a Web-browsing machine?

I currently own a backflip. I like it but it seems to be slow at times!! I want to no wat u suggest. Only thing I can think that my phone has over the i-phone is free apps!! pleaz help cause I can still give this phone back and get an i-phone. Thanks jay

i cant stop rubbing my backflip in my iphone owning friends faces! this phone is the best ive ever owned and used. FTW motoblur i can track my phone if its lost even if its turned off. universal inbox.best google maps by far. all those mindless iphone apps you love are in android market place too. better camera. faster processing than iphone forsure! i also have a warranty unlike that apple piece of shit...oh hey nice shattered screen dude too bad u have to spend $300 for a new phone.

I phone better that back flip in all ways

Personally, I think that the iPhone would be a better choice for you. I'm guessing that you're in your early teens (13,14,15,16) judging by the fact you need to request for your parents to buy you a device. I'm 13 myself, so I envy you! However, the things iPhone does (Web, Texting, Apps, etc) are much superior than the Backflip. I know that children love the appstore for games. I personally have just two games on my iPod touches, as I think it's a music/web browsing device. The App Store has a Larger amount of apps (doesn't mean they're always better), and the web browsing capabilities are far superior to the Backflip. The only reason I can think of getting the Backflip is the QWERTY keyboard, which is (IMO) subpar to the Env3.

i agree with you that the iphone is way bettter cause it has wi fi appps ipod and ect

well i have the iphone3G now NOT 3GS,i want the backflip really bad but i need to convince my dad first. please help me out thanks!

you should probably earn it yourself so you dont have to wait plus it wont take long because its only $99.00 so just baby sit

Backflips rule!!! iPhone sucks balls camera sucks and apple sucks

um im pretty sure the iPhone has a 2 mega pixel camera and my iphone is pretty slow and its brand new im getting the backflip because its way faster in texting and everything else totally disagree with this post

When you say that you disagree with the post, are you talking about the article I wrote, or the person who posted above you?

Well as far as I can say the backflip is truely a magnificant phone. I had an ihpone 3g and this phone out performs the iphone on so many levels (cept battery life, and only cause I had it plugged into my car most of the time). Right now I am writing this comment from my backflip while streaming music to my bluetooth headset from pandora (option iphone does not have) while using this browser and connected to my wifi network. I believe this phone multitasks amazingly well compared to my iphone. Motorola has been a favorite manufacturer of mine for many products and this has deff impressed me. I think apple is a giant which relies to heavily on its fan boy crowd and like all giants will hit the ground hard. Apple is afraid of competition, but I think its healthy for the company and that other comapnies are capable of making great products to pit against apple. This way neither side will settle they wll always strive for inginuity

A great phone for busy lifestyles, and a great organization tool as well as fun. You will lose your iphone but not this baby.

I'm not convinced this is a useful comparison. First off, it should be apparent by now that AT&T has an established history of artificially hobbling competing handsets that show signs of overshadowing the iPhone in any meaningful way. The Backflip is no exception. The bloat, the substitution of the Yahoo widget for Google's widget, and the block on running non-Marketplace apps are all examples of this. In short, that the iPhone comes out on top is a foregone conclusion by design rather than by any virtue of Apple. That said, I think it's worth noting that an update to Android 2.1 is in the works for the Backflip, with signs pointing toward increased performance and gestures support like the pinch zoom. Indications are that this update will become available over the air in the next month or two. Most crucially, though the devices sport substantial feature overlap, I get the impression that they are intended for different audiences. Though it's certainly flexible enough to get the job done (there's an app for that ;) ), the iPhone isn't natively geared for social networking buffs to the degree of the Backflip, and having the potential to be free (with a contract) is a big feather in the Backflip's cap.

If u update a motorola backflip it whoops the iphones butt

I now use my IPHONE as a door stop.

The BackFlip features REMOTE Handset data wipe and data retrieval, Universal inbox, external battery, its insurable, you can locate a lost phone using GPS, Thousands of FREE apps, No comparison BYE IPHONE

Two words: Yahoo Search. That is probably the largest complaint that I've had with this device. I've played with it for a while in the store, and I can say that Backtrack is pretty cool, but the AT&T bloatware and tiny screen are huge turnoffs.

Hmm. I have remote data wipe as well as remote GPS location for my iPhone...although I do have to pay for MobileMe to do that :) I'm with you on the universal inbox thing though. That's probably my biggest issue with the iPhone right now.

SORRY IPHONE. BACKFLIP ALL DAY! ANDROID FTW!

i was about to buy an iphone. then i realized how baaaad it is

so it is tht much better than a iphone is the battery better?

Processor clockspeed comparisons are meaningless unless the processors are of the same architecture.