iPhone 5 vs. iPhone 2G design comparison: Apple paying homage? [Gallery]

PhoneDog Media Exclusive
Download iM5, now available in the App Store and Google Play. iM5 is a PhoneDog Media backed Social Platform to inspire real-life action through the crowdsourcing of ideas. See the video

This year is the iPhone’s 5th anniversary. Since its launch in 2007, the iPhone has taken on a few different forms but all with the same simplistic face. The rectangle with rounded corners and a single home button make it the most recognizable phone on the market. To see just how far we’ve come in terms of design, I’ve put the iPhone 5 side-by-side with the original “Jesus phone” to spot similarities and differences.

Similarities

It goes without saying that the front panel looks virtually identical to the patented design from 5 years back. I doubt Apple’s going to change it any time soon. The software is designed to make full use of that single home button, and a change in software would almost certainly mean a change in hardware resulting in fragmentation.

Apple pays homage to the original iPhone by re-adopting the aluminum two-tone design. Although the materials and exact working out of the bi-color application is different, the reasons for it are the same. It all has to do with radio signals getting through. Metal blocks them, so a “window” is needed. In the 2G it was plastic/polycarbonate. The 5 uses two glass “gaps”. One on the top, and one on the bottom.

One thing that I am glad about returning: individually machined holes for the speaker and mic. The mesh covering on the iPhone 4/4s’ underside coupled with the huge 30-pin connector made it ugly. The iPhone 5 doesn’t have an ugly angle. It’s gone back to the design that looks much more purposeful/deliberate, not just a “cover up that hole with something” approach.
.

Differences

The most apparent difference is the size. The original iPhone (as you’d expect) is much thicker and wider than the newest handset. iPhone 5 is incredibly slim, and is perfectly flat top and bottom, with minimal chamfers on the edges to avoid right-angled discomfort. Gone is the decorative chrome trim that featured on the first three generation iPhones, replaced by a more subtle dark anodized aluminum frame and back panel (on the black version). That said, the iPhone 2G is very comfortable to hold thanks to its rounded, ergonomic shape.

The more subtle difference include the volume controls and front facing camera. Thanks to the addition of FaceTime to Apple’s service-arsenal, the new iDevices all have front facing snappers. The new one just happens to be HD too. Control-wise, the volume rocker has been replaced with two individual “+” and “-” buttons (the same featured on the 4S/4). Much more solid, and better response from presses. The mute switch has changed to a more solid metal design too, as has the lock button.

The headset jack has moved to the bottom for the first time, taking inspiration from the iPod touch, and the camera has gained a LED flash for night-time/low light shooting of drunken teenagers at parties. (Seriously – I aways have it switched off.) Perhaps a less noticeable difference to many is the change in headset jack design. The original phone wasn’t designed to be used with third party accessories unless they were tailor made. The recessed jack meant that a lot of pre-existing headsets couldn’t fit in. Thankfully, the current design has the jack input right on the surface.

Obviously, over time capabilities and performance have evolved with time. And, although the basic interface of iOS is largely unchanged, what you can do with it now compared to the original iPhone OS 1.0 has improved exponentially. You couldn’t even download third party apps on the first-gen model!

Which design features do you prefer from the first iPhone? Which elements of the iPhone 5 impress you? Leave your opinion in the comments or tweet: @TiP_Cam

Gallery

Tags: , , , , ,

  • DarrenButz

    “a change in hardware would almost certainly mean a change in hardware ”
    You don’t say!?

  • SuarezJimmy

    Great article Cam

  • KVKdragon

    It’s always really cool to look at apple’s tech past compared to current models. It really makes you think of those days then compared to now :)

  • joshseawell

    @TiP_Cam you really went old school with that comparison didn’t you??

  • crazydude1998

    @TiP_Cam Man….you have really mentioned your iPhone 2G well, has it ever been broken?

  • Tuliomesa82

    Lol the flame wars are funny. I just got an iphone 4 that has ios 4.3.3 preloaded and damn talk about the lack of features compared to my android phone. I guess people will hate on android because they think of ots android its bound to be buggy. Let me remind you the bugs found in ios 4 and 5. If there was such thing as the perfect ios then we wouldnt be on ios 4.3.3 or ios 5.1.1 you get the point? Same goes with android we have 2.1 2.2 2.3 ect.. all os have bugs. Ios doesnt implement features android has because if it did do it from ios 1 they wouldnt have any new features to sell to the consumer. People think and look back what are you really buying with your iphone? Nothing but outdated features. Apple is a master of manipulation. They keep features away from you add it to the next iphone and make u think you need them. Look at siri it only works with the 4s when its been shown it works perfectly with the 3gs. Maybe now you will understand why android fans hate apple. They make you think you need the new iphone to get the new feature hence siri etc. android doesnt make you do that.

  • TiP_Cam

     @DarrenButz lol! Thanks for spotting. I’ll update it. Schoolboy error.. 

  • DarrenButz

     @TiP_Cam lol no problem

  • TiP_Cam

    @crazydude1998 I only got it in May this year. lol Cost me £80 on ebay

  • TiP_Cam

    @joshseawell I did. No school like the old school..

  • CasperTek

    @TiP_Cam I hear the new school is quite nice … @joshseawell

  • Guest911

    @Tuliomesa82 android fans hate coz they are jealous and need to validate their sorry lives.

  • TiP_Cam

    @CasperTek Hahaha. iPhone 5? Best iPhone ever.. by a long way. Display is much more vivid and crisp. @joshseawell

  • CasperTek

    @TiP_Cam I know. Holding both right now. lol @joshseawell

  • TiP_Cam

    @CasperTek Did you line up or pre-order? @joshseawell

  • CasperTek

    @TiP_Cam Pre-order.

  • TiP_Cam

    @CasperTek Sensible.

  • crazydude1998

    @TiP_Cam wow. still excellent condition for 80 pounds

  • TiP_Cam

    @crazydude1998 It’s been opened up and had the battery replace. But, can’t complain. Works fine.

  • samichaels96

    I see more differences than similarities between the two.

  • Tuliomesa82

    @Guest911 how is that even a valid argument? You fail next please

  • Scottyb112

    @Guest911 Haha, idiot.. If we were jealous we would have the iPhone. That made no sense. I look at the the iPhone an it just shouts boring. Now seeing the iPhone 5 compared to the 2g, it’s even worse. It looks the same. I had one iPhone once an would never go back. Guess what, zero jealousy here

  • George Maguire

    It’s very interesting to see that Apple have taken a look at the first gen model and re-used some ideas. Personally I think the styling of the first gen was the best, and still is. The iPhone 5 looks pretty slick though, however I actually prefer the headset socket on the top of the phone.
     
    George.