Is the original iPhone the best designed?

Jony Ive has become an incredible icon since joining Apple. His work is recognized as being some of the most important and recognizable products of the last ten years. iPod, iPhone and MacBooks have all started life on Sir Jonathan’s desk. So important are his designs that it’s lead to him being the recipient of countless awards, and being knighted by the Queen. Let’s just say, he knows what he’s doing with a pencil.

Something I’ve always despaired at on the newest iPhone shape (present since 2010), is the flat, shiny back. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve moaned to someone about it, or turned my dislike in to a frustrated scrawl on this blog. It’s impractical, and feels terrible.

It was designed to look great, and seemingly that was its one and only aim. The glass panel, and chrome Apple logo and FCC notices do look fantastic. But, thanks to it being so slippery and unpleasant to hold, I’ve always got a case or cover on it, taking away from its main purpose. Naked, the iPhone will slip off any surface, no matter how flat. All it takes is one of my kids to run across the floor, and the vibrations will send it despairingly floorwards as gravity has its wicked way with my friction-free smartphone. That plus the sharp, right angled corners mean that it’s nowhere near as pleasant to grip as my old 3GS was.

I’m not sure if the following statement is regarded as a serious enough atrocity to be labelled a confession. However, I never owned the first generation iPhone. When it was launched in the UK, it was hideously expensive and available on a competitor carrier. I worked for T-mobile at the time, and it was only available on O2. So, I never bought one. Until now.

It’s been 5 years since the original iPhone was released, and they’re available pretty cheap on Ebay, so I slapped down £80 and it arrived this morning. Before seeing it in the flesh, I’d seen it as being a little ugly, but in “real life” it looks gorgeous. It’s the best looking iPhone that was ever released – in my opinion. Not only that, it has perfectly rounded edges that make it feel fantastic in hand. Its smooth Aluminum back mean it doesn’t feel anywhere near as plasticcy as the 3G/3GS, or as slippery as the 4/4S.

Currently, I’m in the car driving down to Wales for a family break. But, you can be sure I’ll be bringing you as much comparison coverage as I can get published, to show the differences in design and performance from the original “Jesus Phone” to the current Apple flagship smartphone. And to judge exactly how far the iPhone has come since 2007.

What would you like to see me compare over the next couple of weeks?

Tags: , , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
AaronGWilson 7 pts

get ready for that pretty aluminum back to be unpretty in about a month or so.......

Haloruler64 84 pts

Thank god someone agrees with me that the 4/4S is terribly designed from a user standpoint. It's uncomfortable to hold.

yazadd 5 pts

I like the design of the 4 and 4s better, and I love that they have interchangeable back plates...but the original iPhone has the upper-hand when it comes to durability. I hated the 3g and 3gs though, because that back plate scratched way to much and made the phone look really ugly after just a couple of minutes. Yes, MINUTES!

JeffWilliams 9 pts

I love the 4S design, personally.  I wish it was more durable, though.  

JeffWilliams 9 pts

I guess I mean the 4 design, since they're the same... lol

boundtobeafraid 12 pts

The other day I met a guy who owned one. It was pretty beat up so I couldn't really tell how beautiful it is ;) I would buy one but all the ones I've seen have a lot of dead pixels.

My fave is the iPhone 4/4S design.

xhannan 6 pts

Definitely 4S .. thinner the better 

ibn_hisham 5 pts

for me i like the design of the original more than 3g/3gs, but i think the 4 is good as well. i think the problem with the original design is Aluminum gets heat!

KyleFrost 25 pts

I agree with most of what you are saying, however, I do have to disagree on the feel of holding the 4/4S. Both my parents own one or the other (you know, same design anyways) and I love the feel. I guess the reason for that is materials and solidity of the device. The plastic 3G/3GS felt, cheap. An iPhone shouldn't feel cheap, because it isn't. But the curve was good at fitting the hand. I think it's just a difference in how we perceive what feels good: actual feel, or sense of materials. I first saw the original iPhone a week after it was launched, my dad's boss of the time bought one for business reasons. It truly is a beautiful device, but wow looking back was it not near what the iPhone is today. If the black plastic at the back could be replaced, and if the thinned it down plus put modern specs inside, that would be the best designed iPhone for sure. No contest. That black plastic bar gets to me though, and the thickness. I can't wait to see some comparisons.

JasonBaroni 6 pts

Of course if you compare with the previously phones before iPhone, yes, but in my point of view, the iPhone 4 design was a huge.

Conversation from Twitter

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E the iPhone 3G/3GS, while fragile and stupidly designed, were incredibly comfortable to hold

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 My thoughts exactly. I loved mine... apart from that fact as a phone it was awful and needed to be replaced 4 times in 1 year

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E I replaced mine 3 in a year. Horrible

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 Constantly I would end up with no service, unusable data speed when I had it and calls + texts would not come in or go out

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E dude, that's iPhone antennas and radios. Even when working perfectly, signal sucked. Android devices rock full signal in places

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E my 3G didn't get data

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 Ahh the times when almost no one had an iPhone. Now everyone has one, and my Note gets more attention that my 3GS did.

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E I've had people come up to me and say "Is that the new Galaxy S??" and go NUTS over dat SAMOLED+

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E One kid recognized my phone, fell in love, and said "the black screen is darker than the bezel!" and got himself a Samsung Skyrocket

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 Reactions I get often "is dat an ipad" "omfg dat phone is huge" "is tha new samsung galaxy!?!" "how doez dat fit in ur pocket"

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E Women like big... phones

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 Men also like big phones..... O_o

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E I do like me some big phone in my hand... O_o best if it's covered in HyperGlaze *SIII reference*

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 The only things I want from the S3 are the faster camera and S Voice

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E I love everything about it

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E Not so much the looks or lack of a black cover

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 for me it's like the One X in some way. Somewhat underwhelming software and hardware.

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E I don't get how it was underwhelming. The specs outclass the One X in every way.

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 Definitely. I love the specs apart from the bland design. Its like the One X in reverse

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E Oh, then I agree! Reverse of the One X. But people say it

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E 's an attractive phone IRL

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 Oh @HTC. Why did you screw up multitasking and take away removable batteries and storage....

Haloruler64
Haloruler64 @Haloruler64 31 May

@573W1E @HTC and added a massive menu button to the bottom of every screen...

573W1E
573W1E @573W1E 31 May

@Haloruler64 @HTC Shame how their best device is on 'one' carrier and pretty much unavailable for everyone